The most recent statistics show that 24 million people in England and Wales are married, which is equivalent to 47% of the population. In the case of all these couples, before the wedding planning began, one of them proposed, probably with an expensive ring. Most couples will be married, but what happens to the engagement ring if the couple do not complete their vows and part ways?
This is not a question many people have pondered. Nevertheless, it is an interesting, albeit rather depressing conundrum and one which the Court had to tackle in the aptly named case of RI v NG [2025].
The Case
In February 2024, Mr. RI proposed to Ms. NG and the wedding was due to take place in May 2025. Unfortunately, they did not make it that far and two weeks before the wedding date, the ceremony was called off. Thereafter, Mr. RI sought the return of the engagement ring and other jewellery worth a total of £68,000, which was given to Ms. NG upon their engagement.
The first question is whether the Court has jurisdiction to deal with this matter, which they do under section 17 of the Married Women’s Property Act 1882, as amended by section 2(2) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1970.
The second, and more interesting question is, would Ms. NG be ordered to return the jewellery? There is a presumption that engagement rings are gifts as per section 3(2) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1970.
However, this presumption is rebuttable if it can be proven that it was gifted on the express or implied condition that it ought to be returned if the marriage did not go ahead. This was indeed proven to be the case in the matter of Mr. RI and Ms. NG. Therefore, the Court ordered that the jewellery be returned to Mr. RI.
Giving an engagement ring has legal consequences and these are worth considering if you plan to propose. A prenuptial agreement may also be worth considering before walking down the aisle. Neither matter tends to be at the forefront of one’s mind when getting engaged, nevertheless, they ought to be given consideration.
Get in Touch
Every couple’s case is unique, with its own set of facts and circumstances, and it is important to seek legal advice that takes into account the specific details of your situation to understand your options.
At Fisher Jones Greenwood, our team of family law experts have a wealth of experience in dealing with matrimonial finances and divorce matters and provide clear advice to guide you through this process.
If you would like advice about matrimonial finances and divorce, please contact our Family Team by filling out our online contact form or call 08082 399 563.